Eagles Mix blog         Write for Eagles blog    

  Eagles Mix blog featured writers Benjamin Baney, C.J Hecht, Nick Popyack
Lance Epstein
  Write about the Eagles
We believe that you the avid fan, student journalist, and or freelance writer deserve to be heard. Avid fans have a strong desire to hear from the common (or not so common) "man" as well. You are always free to write about the material of your choice, in your own unique style, and on your own schedule. So vent,enlighten and share with us!
Contact us at: writers@sportsmixed.com
  Enjoy Eagles rumors, news, talk?
Please help us spread the word on the Sports Mixed Network by letting friends, and family know about it. The more we grow our community of avid fans, the more features we can add. So please send a Tweet, Facebook message or better yet tell them in person.

Did The Eagles Have One Of The Worst Offseasons?

Clayton: Eagles Fifth Worst Offseason In NFL

By Lance Epstein

Instead of staying the course and heading into the 2010 season with practically the same roster intact after being humiliated by the Dallas Cowboys [twice] to end the season, head coach Andy Reid and general manager Howie Roseman were determined to make drastic changes to the squad.

The Eagles liberated themselves of aging and overpriced veterans such as Chris Clemons, Darren Howard and Kevin Curtis. Furthermore, the Eagles decided to move the franchise in an entirely different direction. After a decade of success under quarterback Donovan McNabb and his ultimate weapon in Brian Westbrook, the franchise dumped the two mainstays in their offense.

Not only did the Eagles lose those two key components, they also traded starting right corner and defensive leader Sheldon Brown to the Cleveland Browns.

While most fans were happy that the organization finally came to the conclusion that it was time to start over with a youth movement and begin the Kevin Kolb era, ESPN's John Clayton has a different take on the situation.

In a recent article on ESPN.com, Clayton listed the top five worst offseasons in the NFL. The Buffalo Bills received the top honor for worst offseason of any franchise. The Minnesota Vikings [second], Arizona Cardinals [third] and New Orleans Saints [fourth] followed the Bills on the list.

The last team on that made the dreaded list was the Philadelphia Eagles at No. 5. It is only fitting that the Eagles were fifth considering the major reason for Clayton included the Birds on the list was due to trading the best quarterback in franchise history, who happened to wear a number five jersey.

Despite the Eagles making on the list, Clayton acknowledges that some experts and analysts would consider the bold moves as the best moves of the entire offseason. Especially due to the fact the Eagles acquired a pass-rushing specialist in Brandon Graham and a starting caliber free safety in Nate Allen via the draft.

"On paper, the Eagles' offseason could be considered one of the best, but the shadow of the Donovan McNabb trade puts good thoughts on hold," Clayton wrote. "The Eagles' aggressiveness worked well in getting good younger players in trades, such as linebackers Ernie Sims and Alex Hall and defensive end Darryl Tapp. An overstuffed draft that ended up with a league-high 13 choices can't be criticized, particularly when the Eagles got a pass-rushing defensive end (Brandon Graham) and a quality young free safety (Nate Allen)."

However, the main reason that Clayton sees the Eagles offseason as one of the worst is because of the timing of the McNabb trade. He insists that the schedule [which includes 11 match-ups against top-tier quarterbacks] makes it very difficult for Kevin Kolb in his first full-year as a starting quarterback to have more success than an experienced McNabb would have provided the Eagles.

Additionally, he compares Kolb's situation to that of Green Bay quarterback Aaron Rodgers, who had a similar predicament in his first year as the starter as he attempted to replace a future Hall of Famer in Brett Favre.

"Bell is a nice addition to backup halfback LeSean McCoy, but the timing of the McNabb trade could bring down the whole team. Kevin Kolb takes over in a season in which the Eagles face 11 top-level quarterbacks, a league high by far," he wrote. "Can Kolb outduel Aaron Rodgers, McNabb (twice), Tony Romo (twice), Eli Manning (twice), Peyton Manning, Matt Schaub, Matt Ryan and Favre? Chances are Kolb will go 4-7 or 3-8 against those arms and limit the Eagles to a six- or seven-win season. That's what happened to Rodgers when the Packers traded Favre to the Jets."

So is Clayton accurate when he claims the Eagles have had one of the worst offseasons in the NFL? Not really because the Eagles do not control the schedule making process. When any team looks to move in another direction and improve the roster, they do not worry about who is on their schedule, but about their individual team. In the NFL, teams cannot solely focus on build a club for just the upcoming season. They must build for the long haul as well.

Obviously, the moves the Eagles made this offseason could mean taking a step backwards, but overall it could be more beneficial for the franchise’s future success. Also, with injuries being what they are in football, the Eagles could luck out and miss some of those big-time quarterbacks.

Could Reid, Joe Banner and Roseman looked at the opponents on the slate before trading McNabb to Washington? Of course, but if the team decided to hold onto McNabb and let him play out the season along with his contract, they would receive nothing in return unless he won a Super Bowl.

When trading away a player with as much value as McNabb encompasses [plus having a young quarterback waiting in the wings], a team cannot wait to pull the trigger based off of schedule. A club must take all the chips they can collect before they end up with empty pockets.

Furthermore, there was a reason that the Eagles were inclined to trade McNabb and inside the division. The organization feels that Kolb, not McNabb, gives the Eagles the best opportunity to win next year.

One area that Clayton should have mentioned and he might have been accurate with his assessment is the lack of talent at cornerback. Unfortunately, he did not even touch on that subject. Anointing an offseason as one of the worst based on trading McNabb with a schedule on the horizon that appears to be brutal is laughable. Especially when the club has a capable QB replacing him and that threw for back-to-back 300-yard games in his first two career starts.

While the fans do not agree with all the moves that were made, they are generally onboard with most of them. The Eagles acquired a defensive end in Graham, who should the pressure off Trent Cole. Additionally, the Eagles acquired a free safety in Allen [with the pick they acquired from the McNabb trade] that can adequately replace the void left behind by Brian Dawkins.

Moreover, the team gets back the heart and soul its defense in middle linebacker Stewart Bradley. Also, Bradley has a new partner in crime in weak-side linebacker Sims, who fits the Eagles defensive scheme very well.

Should the Eagles have gone out and found a better replacement for Brown than Hobbs? Probably, but Hobbs could still prove doubters wrong. Did the organization make a mistake by not having a better plan in place incase center Jamaal Jackson is not ready by week 1? Maybe. However, those two issues were not even touched upon by Clayton.

If a schedule is the key to a having a bad offseason, then the Houston Texans should be tops on this list since they possess the hardest strength of schedule.

8 comments:

  1. Homer! Team is doomed, you lost all writing credibility when you said Allen can adequitely replace Dawkins. You're just as bad as Clayton, supposing. The draft is a joke and does not translate to anything concrete, it's a crapshoot, while Dawkins is still a game changer, McNabb a game changer. I been watching since 1980, 30 years is enough. Kolb, really, Kolb, as in Corn on the....

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think it all is gonna fall into how Kobb performs. If he is basing all of this on the trade of mcnabb, then it becomes a mute point if Kobb performs well. That remains to be seen. I have my fingers corssed, but not alot of faith even thou the Birds have a good record of letting players go just in time to see them slide.

    ReplyDelete
  3. maybe cuz the Texans did get worst all they got on kevin flop is the 300 yards games look a the teams not really good teams right the eagles got worst at QB and CB and thats why they are the 5 worst team in the offseason

    ReplyDelete
  4. Im just glad we dont have to watch mcFlab suck wind any more.

    Except when we play him...

    ReplyDelete
  5. TWGOLD

    You've got to rebuild at some point, at least Kolb has three years watching. Thats how it use to be, Y.A. Tittle sat for many years and he made the switch the same could happen here. GO EAGLES

    ReplyDelete
  6. "maybe cuz the Texans did get worst all they got on kevin flop is the 300 yard games look at the teams not reall good teams" ONE of those teams was the super bowl champions, New Orleans Saints. Don't say something that makes you look dumb.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Dawkins is DONE, you clowns need to move on from the Dawkins era already. How did Dawkins help that Denver collapse down the stretch?

    Mcnabb was NEVER going to win a title in philly, he's not a fit for this offense, anyone awake and watching already knew this. This offense needs an accurate QB who can anticipate, lead receivers and get rid of the ball quickly, hit them in stride. Mcnabb does little to none of this.

    My biggest concerns going forward are
    1. Center
    2. Secondary

    ReplyDelete
  8. you have to look no further than our own phillies and flyers to determine what is needed to be succesful.......heart and grit.... we know the birds have the talent, and being so young, they shoud have something to prove. i think they are going to suprise alot of peope this year. i haven't been this pumped about the birds in a long time !!!!!

    ReplyDelete